Wine growing is a tough business. My late friend Mike Finucane used to joke that the best way to end up with a small fortune in wine is to start with a large one. Success attracts corporate interest, and so does failure, whether financial or through succession challenges. The sales pitch is always irresistible: investment, upgraded facilities, winemaking independence, and marketing support. But when the honeymoon ends, the marriage is too often disappointing.
Just months ago, I wrote about New Zealand’s world-leading position in sustainable viticulture. Imagine my chagrin to see the current corporate owners of one of our most iconic brands, Villa Maria, retreating from organics. Indevin has reportedly converted 100 of its 130 hectares of organic vines back to conventional farming. Vinarchy, owner of Brancott Estate, has done the same with half its organic holdings.
Organic viticulture is seldom driven by short-term financial returns. Yet there is ample evidence that organics can be financially sustainable when paired with thoughtful premiumisation. Too many corporates, however, seem to lack the patience or marketing skill to build strong premium brands. Instead, the strategy resembles a race to the bottom: volume over value, retreat from environmental commitments, and relentless cost-cutting.
Vinarchy, the mega-entity formed from Accolade Wines and Pernod Ricard’s Australian, New Zealand and Spanish assets, is centralising production into two industrial hubs while closing historic wineries and reportedly dropping dozens of established brands. Indevin’s takeover of Villa Maria shows similar patterns. Vidal Estate and Esk Valley have disappeared, Gisborne vineyards have been ripped out, and Villa Maria’s flagship Ngakirikiri has remained at much the same price for a decade while competitors continue to build premium value. Bulk shipping and offshore bottling may improve short-term profits, but they erode the emotional premium attached to New Zealand wine. Retailers quickly learn to view you as interchangeable, and they are relentless in extracting value.
Sustainability in wine must be values-driven as well as financially sustainable. Wine lovers do not buy wine as a commodity. We buy legacy, history, environmental commitment, terroir, and the winemaker’s passion.

